Where the mess becomes the masterpiece.

← Back to Desserts for a Crowd

Cake Mix Cookies, 8 Ways

Oven · 350°F · 9–12 minutes a pan (standard steps — the pin listed ingredients only)

Pairs with: Cake/Cupcake Dry Mix

Chaos rating: Level 4 — Full Blown MessLevel 4 Full Blown Mess flameLevel 4 Full Blown Mess flameLevel 4 Full Blown Mess flameLevel 4 Full Blown Mess flame

Ingredients

Directions

  1. THE BASIC ROUTE (every flavor): heat the oven to 350°F and line cookie sheets with parchment. Stir the cake mix with its wet ingredients into a soft dough, scoop tablespoon-size balls onto the sheets 2 inches apart, bake 9–12 minutes until the edges are set, and cool on the pan 5 minutes before moving them.
  2. GRINCH: stir the vanilla mix, oil, eggs and vanilla together and tint the dough green. Stir the confectioners sugar and cornstarch together in a small bowl, roll each ball in the mixture, bake, and press a candy heart (or a pinch of sprinkles) into the top while the cookies are still warm.
  3. LEMON: stir the lemon mix, oil, eggs and vanilla together, bake plain, and let the cookies cool completely. Melt the almond bark and dip each cookie halfway; set them on parchment until the coating firms up.
  4. STRAWBERRY: melt the butter and stir it with the strawberry mix, eggs, strawberry syrup, lemon juice and baking soda. Fold in the white chocolate chips and bake.
  5. CHRISTMAS: stir the white mix, eggs and clear soda together — the soda is the liquid, so the dough will be soft. Fold in the M&Ms and white chocolate chips, shower sprinkles over the tops, and bake.
  6. FUNFETTI: stir the funfetti mix, sprinkles, baking soda, sour cream, eggs and vanilla together. Scoop, add more sprinkles on top, and bake.
  7. PUMPKIN: stir the vanilla mix, pumpkin pie spice and pumpkin puree together — no eggs or oil in this one, the puree does that job. Fold in the pecans, bake, cool completely, and frost with the tub frosting.
  8. RED VELVET: stir the red velvet mix, eggs and whipped cream cheese into a soft dough; chill 30 minutes if it is sticky. Roll the balls in the powdered sugar and bake.
  9. RAINBOW: stir the white mix, eggs, oil, flour and vanilla together. Split the dough into bowls and tint each one a different color with the gel coloring. Pinch pieces of each color together into marbled balls and bake.
← Back to Desserts for a Crowd
Bizzy